Joe’s Pizza

Reviews

• Tim S.

  star star star star star 6 June 2026

  Joe's Pizza is about as NYC as it gets, and for that you should definitely make it a stop.  We wanted to go to the original on Carmine street but were in Times Square and it was getting late so opted for this location.
  
  We went for a regular cheese slice which was piping hot and absolutely delicious.  While you can throw a rock in NYC and find good pizza, Joe's reputation precedes itself for being one of the top spots and for good reason, the pizza is absolutely delicious.
  
  Note that it's definitely not a dollar-slice joint and you'll definitely want to keep in mind that slices are between $3-$5 but absolutely worth it.  If I had more time, I definitely would've tried the Sicilian, Fresh Mozzarella and White slices.  They looked absolutely delicious and will be my next move when I'm back.

• V W.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 29 May 2026

  I tried Joe's Pizza for the first time 2 weeks ago on a whim and I greatly regretted it.
  
  Just because your pizza joint has been featured in a movie does not mean you're pizza is any good-- sorry to be that blunt but it's true.
  
  I really wanted to like this place but man what a freaking let down.
  
  I ordered a sausage pizza that had onions and I didn't know that the onions on it would be almost raw and not throughly cooked. It was pretty gross to say the least!
  
  I had one slice after peeling the onions off and the worst part was that the pizza itself was very soggy and had little to none sauce.
  
  The whole pizza onions or not was just not executed right. I ended up paying over $40 for a pizza I didn't enjoy and ended up throwing the rest away. What a shame!
  
  Any who-- Joe's Pizza gets a 2 thumbs way way down.

• Michele G.

  star star star star star_border 23 May 2026

  Very busy pizza place located by times square.
  Had to drop by and try a slice of pizza; ordered a pepperoni pizza and it was huge. It's $5 for a slice so it was not bad.
  Pizza was really fresh and piping hot. Crust was nice and crunchy. I'm not the biggest fan of pizza, but this pizza was pretty good. However there is barely any seating which was not great because I don't enjoy eating things on the go. Lots of tourists as well so it got quite loud inside.

• Mich M.

  star star star star star 22 May 2026

  Very pricey slices. $4 for a pepperoni slice and $3 for a regular cheese slice. Absolutely delicious! There's always a huge line outside the doors of any Joe's Pizza.
  
  Great place for a quick bite. Or order for a party!

• Casey Lyn B.

  star star star star star 19 May 2026

  Finally, out of all the times I've been in NYC, I get to try one of the places that sell NY Pizza. I wanted to see what all the hype is about. During my stay, I went here twice. First time was near closing time, which wasn't busy as much as during lunch time. FYI, if you go during busy hours, the line can go all the way outside. So, make sure you're not super hungry!
  
  I tried the cheese, and caprese. Something so simple makes it so good. Thin crust, nice sauce, not too much cheese. It just seemed well-balanced.
  
  I would highly recommend and for tourists to try to get a New York feel. Having this restaurant located in Time Square, parking it very difficult!